Tuesday, August 14

I'll Say His Name: Jon Krakauer

If you've seen the latest issue of Esquire magazine, you've probably read about Sean Penn's latest directorial project, Into the Wild. What's blatantly missing in the article is the name Jon Krakauer, who wrote the book on which the movie is based. I read in the article that Penn has been in hot pursuit of the film rights for about ten years, and the film is getting pre-release rave reviews.

Funny though, that the article's author Scott Raab, chose to leave out the 1992 Best Seller author's name, but what more publicity does Krakauer need after that whole Into Thin Air controversy anyway, right?

As I've told a few blogger friends, I'm a big Krakauer fan, but for different reasons than you may think. While very popular amongst most readers, Into Thin Air is my least favorite book that Krakauer has written. It read like he was still in shock from all the events that happened that dreaded day on Everest back in May, 1996. Well, who wouldn't be? The problem is, he admittedly was affected by the altitude and exhaustion that day, and may not have recalled all the events accurately. My sister and I really got into reading everything we could on the matter. If we were blogging back when we read all the subsequent books, we undoubtedly would have had numerous posts and discussions about this.

Aren't you all lucky?

On the other hand, I found Into the Wild to be a compelling, well-written story. Krakauer has been criticized for annoyingly comparing his own life and adventures to his book subjects such as in this book but it didn't bother me. His obvious obsession with the story of the main character - Christopher McCandless was another intricacy to the book that I for one, enjoyed.

But that's not even why I like my fellow Boulderite. Mostly, I like Krakauer because he has my dream job. He gets paid to go out on adventures, to go climb, and then writes about it. I want to be him, or at least the female version of him. He's been spotted at the top of a hard rock or ice climb around here, kicking back, having a doobie, and writing in his little notepad. That beats me sitting inside all day, drinking Red Bull, and writing about computer geeky stuff any day of the week.

As for the movie, it's going to be a rare event for me. I'll actually go see it in the theater when it comes out and I suggest you do the same. I've read from more than one source that Emile Hirsch (soon to be Speed Racer too) does a fantastic job as McCandless, an intense rich kid who sets out to find himself in the back country of Alaska. I won't say more just in case you're not familiar with the story, but I'll give you a hint - Hirsch lost 41 pounds to play the role and he was only 156 lbs. to begin with.

The Esquire article revealed Penn, an intense person himself, pushed Hirsch during filming every step of the way. He wanted him to look so afraid during the river kayaking scene that he didn't let him practice or learn anything about kayaking before placing him in the boat. After surveying the white water section of the frigid river he was to float, Hirsch wasn't so sure about doing it. But Penn made him a deal - if Penn did it first, then he would follow, and that's how it happened.

As with Krakauer's pursuit of the McCandless story, I am not surprised that Sean Penn sought to tell this story in a movie. He's the exact Hollywood person I would have picked to do the story justice. I think the former twenty-something bad boy can identify with McCandless' tale.

16 players in the box:

Grant Miller said...

JK can do no wrong in my book. He's brilliant. I've read everything I can find by him. And the Alaska story might be his best. I didn't realize it was being made into a movie, though.

kirby said...

I read a blurb about this movie in the latest issue of NG Adventure magazine. I can't wait to see it.

Skylers Dad said...

This sounds awesome, I can't wait!

vikkitikkitavi said...

Saw some previews. You'll be happy to hear that it looks good.

GETkristiLOVE said...

I forgot to include the trailer.

Skylers Dad said...

Kristi, the trailer gave me chills...

Chris said...

I really liked his book about the Mormons. I converted based on his flattering portrayal.

kirby said...

The trailer looks good. Normally, William Hurt would be a deal breaker for me. I'll make an exception here.

Megan said...

Haven't read any of his stuff except Under the Banner of Heaven (also known as "his book about the Mormons"), but I may check him out.

vikkitikkitavi said...

Like my sister, I've read all Krakauer's books. I would say that Into the Wild is the most compelling because of its accessibility. What I found most beautiful and surprising about it is that even though McCandless makes plenty of heart-breaking mistakes in his life, somehow, you end up being with him on all of them.

I also really admire Into Thin Air, I think more so than my sister. Because I have never been on a mountain (Bear Peak don't count!) my ignorance makes me judge Krakauer less harshly, I believe. Into Thin Air is unique among his books because he is a participant in the story. Into Thin Air can be a bit of a challenge as well if you are not well-acquainted with mountaineering terminology, as I wasn't.

Johnny Yen said...

Into Thin Air was one of those rare books that I could not put down until I was finished. What a compelling story.

lulu said...

Into the Wild was a favorite Indie Reading book of my students back in Chicago. I think they started reading it because it looked short, but most of them got really caught up in the story. There will probably be a pirated version of the movie available here a week after it gets released....

GETkristiLOVE said...

One thing stuck out when I read Under the Banner of Heaven - it was so thoroughly researched and footnoted, to the point of nausea even, that I wondered if Krakauer was trying to make up for writing things in Into Thin Air that he regrets.

Not to rehash, but if you are so inclined to read some of the issues and things that JK had to take back from the book (which aren't widely publicized, like the book).

I will say that while I still love JK, I think he broke the unwritten rule when he wrote that book: You don't judge people when 1) their own life is on the line, whether they are a guide or not and 2) they weren't there. True, JK was on the mountain, but he wasn't present at every place at every moment when things/screwups/decisions were made. Plus, his own judgement was impaired during the events.

Case in point - Sir Edmund Hillary's outlash towards double amputee Mark Inglis' group leaving a dying climber just below the Hillary Step - Hillary wasn't there, he didn't know the situation, and there's not much you can do at that altitude to help someone in the first place.

Is it gallant that guide Rob Hall died along side of his client, Doug Hansen, or should he have gotten himself down when he knew he was in trouble? He may have gone back to New Zealand damned as a guide, but he'd be alive to be a husband and father to his new baby girl.

A mountain like Everest will test your very essence of why you walk the earth. The reality is that if you try and help a dying person above a certain altitude, you most-likely are resigning to die yourself. If you do help and you die, you die a hero. If you don't help, you're a self-centered asshole. It's a Kobayashi Maru situation.

Grant Miller said...

I read the paperback "Into Thin Air" first. But there's a coffee table version of the book with tons of pictures, maps etc. that I found much more helpful. It provided far more detail than JK's narrative alone ever could.

Major Bedhead said...

I think I've read all of his books except Under The Banner Of Heaven - I just couldn't finish it.

I loved Into The Wild. I didn't know there was a movie coming out - I'm definitely going to see that.

Cascade_Sasquatch said...

I can't stand JK becuase of his complete lack of responsibilty in his writings. While his writing is excellent and he tells compelling stories, he doesn't give any reguard to factual information. This wouldn't be an issue if he were a fiction author, which is were JK belongs.